munotes®

B.A. LL.B. (Five Years) Sem 4 Logic 2 2025-26 ATKT 60/40 Question Paper - Mumbai University | munotes

Logic 2 Question Paper, 2025.pdf
SEM 4 · 1.5 MB · 6 Aug 2026

Loading PDF...

Questions asked in this paper

Solved paper All 42 questions answered in full Exam-ready answers, the reasoning behind each one, and what the examiner is looking for. Open the solutions

Q.1 Code 57212, form 96764, Q1. Answer the following in one or two sentences (any 6 of 10) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Give any 2 kinds of uses of language.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) What is the minor term in categorical syllogism?
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) What is the fallacy of illicit major term?
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Name any 2 valid moods in the second figure.
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) What is direct reduction?
    Read the model answer
  6. (f) What is direct verification?
    Read the model answer
  7. (g) Name any two types of dilemma.
    Read the model answer
  8. (h) What is a fallacy of ad verecundiam?
    Read the model answer
  9. (i) State the rule in the following- (p . q) ≡ (q . p)
    Read the model answer
  10. (j) State the rule of Modus Ponens.
    Read the model answer

Q.2 Code 57212, Q.2 Write short notes on (any 2 of 4) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Kinds of agreement and disagreements.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Disjunctive syllogism.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Common sense views of causation.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Oskar Schindler case.
    Read the model answer

Q.3 Code 57212, Q.3. Answer (any 2 of 3) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Test the validity of the following categorical syllogisms, state the figure & give reason.
    • (1) No American is an Indian. Some Indians are lazy; hence Americans are never lazy.
    • (2) All scholars get freeship. Mohan is a scholar. So, Mohan gets freeship.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Reduce the mood BOCARDO indirectly.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Identify the kind of non-formal fallacies, if any, in the following, giving reason.
    • (1) I failed in the examination as I forgot to wear my lucky shirt on the day of examination.
    • (2) Why were you lying that day?
    • (3) It is wrong to tell a lie. So, a doctor telling a lie to a dying patient is wrong too.
    Read the model answer

Q.4 Code 57212, Q.4. Any one question from questions a, b, c. Question 'd' is compulsory (any 1 of 3, and d) 24 Marks

  1. (a) Discuss the structural rules and rules of quality of a categorical syllogism and the fallacies that arise from their violation.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Discuss the conditions of a good hypothesis and explain why each is necessary.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Discuss the maxim "In jure non remota causa sed proxima spectator": In law, the immediate and not the remote cause is considered. Illustrate with cases
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Construct a complex constructive dilemma. Rebut & refute it. If my screen time is more then I spoil my eyes and if my screen time is less, then my work is incomplete.
    Read the model answer

Q.1 Code 66852, form 96768, the second paper on the scan, 2.30 hrs, Q1. Answer the following in one or two sentences (any 6 of 8) 12 Marks

  1. (a) What is the fallacy of the undistributed middle term?
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) How many figures are there in the categorical syllogism?
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Name any 2 valid moods in the second figure
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) What is Aristotle's Dictum de omni et nullo?
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) What are the types of destructive dilemma?
    Read the model answer
  6. (f) What is a fallacy of composition?
    Read the model answer
  7. (g) Symbolise and state the rule in the following, If it rains, the ground is wet; ground is not wet. so it didn't rain.
    Read the model answer
  8. (h) State the rule of material implication.
    Read the model answer

Q.2 Code 66852, Q.2 Write short notes on (any 2 of 4) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Plurality of causes.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Hypothetical syllogism.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Informative use of language in reasoning.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Joan Andrews case.
    Read the model answer

Q.3 Code 66852, Q.3. Answer (any 2 of 4) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Test the validity of the following categorical syllogisms, state the figure & give reason.
    • (1) All doctors are respected. Since doctors are professionals, every professional is respected.
    • (2) Girls are never quiet. No quiet person is an introvert. So no introvert is a girl.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Reduce the mood BAROCO indirectly
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Identify the kind of non-formal fallacies, if any, in the following, giving reason.
    • (1) Division D is talkative, hence Riya, who is a student of this Division must also be talkative.
    • (2) This book is interesting. so every page of it is also interesting.
    • (3) How can he commit a crime when we know that he is a grandson of a freedom fighter.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Evaluate the following inferences and identify whether it commits a fallacy or not. Give a reason.
    • (1) If I go to Delhi, then I visit Agra. I don't visit Agra. So I don't visit Delhi.
    • (2) Either you are a Hindu or a Muslim. You are a Hindu. So you are not a Muslim.
    Read the model answer

Q.4 Code 66852, Q.4. Any two questions from questions a, b, c, d. Question 'e' is compulsory (any 2 of 4, and e) 39 Marks

  1. (a) Explain the popular notion of causation.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Discuss the stages of the hypothesis with an illustration.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) State the rules of distribution of the categorical syllogism along with the fallacies if any.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Peter Singer's view on equality and justice.
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) Construct a complex constructive dilemma. Rebut & refute it. If I invest money in mutual funds then my EMI is pending & if I don't invest in mutual funds then my future is insecure.
    Read the model answer

Read from the scan above, so a character or two may differ. The scan is the original.

Issue

Something wrong on this page? Report it and we will check it against the scan.

Quick Help

No. The full paper opens straight away, with no login and nothing to pay.

Something wrong with this paper? Report it.

Done!
Done!