munotes®

B.A. LL.B. (Five Years) Sem 4 Logic 2 2025-26 Question Paper - Mumbai University | munotes

Logic 2 Question Paper, 2025.pdf
SEM 4 · 973 KB · 5 Aug 2026

Loading PDF...

Questions asked in this paper

Solved paper All 21 questions answered in full Exam-ready answers, the reasoning behind each one, and what the examiner is looking for. Open the solutions

Q.1 Q.1 Answer the following in not more than two sentences (any 6 of 8) 12 Marks

  1. (a) What's "Vis major"?
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) State the rule of hypothetical syllogism.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) What mediate inference?
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Which are the figures given by Aristotle himself?
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) State the rule in the following -Mumbai is in India & New York in the US. Hence Mumbai is in India.
    Read the model answer
  6. (f) When is the fallacy of composition committed?
    Read the model answer
  7. (g) What is anumana as per Nyaya school of Philosophy.
    Read the model answer
  8. (h) Give symbolic expression of simple destructive dilemma.
    Read the model answer

Q.2 Q.2 Write short notes (any 2 of 4) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Reduction of a figure.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Working hypothesis.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Disjunctive arguments.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Prove the special rules of Figure II of a categorical syllogism.
    Read the model answer

Q.3 Q3. Attempt any two of the following sub questions (any 2 of 4) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Test the validity of the following syllogisms, state their figure & mood.
    • (i) Meena is an engineer as many girls are engineers and Meena is a girl.
    • (ii) If shopkeepers are all businessmen, they are not all merchants, as not every businessman is a merchant.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Reduce the mood Dimaris directly.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Identify the nonformal fallacies, if any, in the following, giving reason.
    • (i) Since when have you stopped lying?
    • (ii) If division 'B 'is disobedient, then for obvious reasons even Ramesh who belongs to the same division is disobedient too.
    • (iii) Everyone is buying this product, so it must be good.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) identify the formal fallacy, if any, in the following, giving reason.
    • (i) If Mohan is a doctor, he is honoured. Since he is honoured, he must be a doctor.
    • (ii) Either Suhas is a student or a teacher. He, being a student, is not a teacher.
    • (iii) If it is a dog, then it is an animal. It is an animal. Therefore, it is a dog.
    Read the model answer

Q.4 Q.4. From the sub questions a, b, c, d, attempt any two & sub question e is compulsory (any 2 of 4, and e) 39 Marks

  1. (e) Explain the general rules of syllogism.
    Read the model answer
  2. (a) Explain in detail the scientific view of cause, how does Mill contribute to it?
    Read the model answer
  3. (b) Explain the problem of "ends and means "with reference to the cases discussed by Peter Singer.
    Read the model answer
  4. (c) Explain Hypothetico deductive method citing an example.
    Read the model answer
  5. (d) Construct a complex constructive dilemma and rebut and refute it. If I pamper my son then he gets spoilt and if I don't pamper him he will get negative reward.
    Read the model answer

Read from the scan above, so a character or two may differ. The scan is the original.

Issue

Something wrong on this page? Report it and we will check it against the scan.

Quick Help

No. The full paper opens straight away, with no login and nothing to pay.

Something wrong with this paper? Report it.

Done!
Done!