munotes®

B.A. LL.B. (Five Years) Sem 4 Logic 2 2024-25 Question Paper - Mumbai University | munotes

Logic 2 Question Paper, 2024.pdf
SEM 4 · 1.2 MB · 5 Aug 2026

Loading PDF...

Questions asked in this paper

  • N.B: 1. Attempt all questions. 2. Figures to the right indicates full marks.
Solved paper All 21 questions answered in full Exam-ready answers, the reasoning behind each one, and what the examiner is looking for. Open the solutions

Q.1 Q.1 Answer the following in one or two sentences (any 6 of 8) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Define mediate inference.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) State the meaning of 'Anumana' with reference to Nyaya logic.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Illustrate the rule of Conjunction.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Identify and illustrate the rule of deductive proof: "You practice martial art regularly. Therefore, either you practice martial art regularly or you play cricket on weekends."
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) Mention any two impediments of good reasoning.
    Read the model answer
  6. (f) Illustrate the fallacy of composition with an example.
    Read the model answer
  7. (g) What is Mill's concept of positive condition with reference to causation?
    Read the model answer
  8. (h) Define Pure hypothetical argument.
    Read the model answer

Q.2 Q.2 Write short notes (any 2 of 4) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Descriptive Hypothesis
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Kinds of dilemma
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Respondent Superior
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Emotively Neutral Language
    Read the model answer

Q.3 Q.3 Answer the following (any 2 of 4) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Test the validity of the following Categorical Syllogism. State the figure and give reason.
    • (i) If every wealthy man is dishonest and no wealthy man is a philosopher, it follows that no dishonest man is a philosopher.
    • (ii) Some industrialists are philanthropists. Since all philanthropists are kind-hearted and many industrialists are kind-hearted.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Reduce indirectly: BAROCO
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Identify the non- formal fallacy, if any and give reason.
    • (i) "Modern surgery is a miracle of science; therefore, man has progressed".
    • (ii) "If we allow students having medical issue to appear for the additional examination, we must allow every absent student to appear for the additional examination."
    • (iii) "The 'x' diet product was endorsed by Mr. Amitabh Bachchan. So, it will beneficial."
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Evaluate the following statements and identify the formal fallacy, if any. Give reason.
    • (i) If Panchtantra contains fables, then it is interesting to read. If it is interesting to read, then it must be recommended. Therefore, If Panchtantra contains fables, then must be recommended.
    • (ii) If fallacies are unavoidable, they would be excusable. Fallacies are not unavoidable. Therefore, Fallacies would not be excusable.
    Read the model answer

Q.4 Q.4 Question no. 4 (e) and any two from (a), (b), (c) and (d) (any 2 of 4, and 4(e)) 39 Marks

  1. (a) Illustrate and discuss the Third and Fourth figures of categorical syllogism.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Define Hypothesis. Describe the conditions of good hypothesis.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Analyse the concept of 'Popular notion of cause.'
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) "The difficult issue is not whether the end can ever justify the means, but which mean is justified by which end."- Comment with refence to the Peter Singer's view on End and Means.
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) Construct a complex constructive dilemma, rebut and refute it. "If a man is in politics, he is corrupt; and if he is disinterested in politics, he is an undesirable citizen".
    Read the model answer

Read from the scan above, so a character or two may differ. The scan is the original.

Issue

Something wrong on this page? Report it and we will check it against the scan.

Quick Help

No. The full paper opens straight away, with no login and nothing to pay.

Something wrong with this paper? Report it.

Done!
Done!