munotes®

B.A. LL.B. (Five Years) Sem 4 Logic 2 2023-24 Question Paper - Mumbai University | munotes

Logic 2 Question Paper, 2023.pdf
SEM 4 · 1.5 MB · 5 Aug 2026

Loading PDF...

Questions asked in this paper

Solved paper All 23 questions answered in full Exam-ready answers, the reasoning behind each one, and what the examiner is looking for. Open the solutions

Q.1 Q.1 Answer the following in one or two sentences (any 6 of 10) 12 Marks

  1. (a) State the rule of Simple constructive Dilemma.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Define hypothesis
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) State the rule of Modus Tollendo Ponens.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Name the four valid moods of all figures of categorical syllogism having 'E' proposition as its conclusion.
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) Identify and symbolise the rule in the following- Either it is raining or it is sunny. It is not raining. Therefore, it is sunny.
    Read the model answer
  6. (f) What is the position of middle term in fig III of the categorical syllogism.
    Read the model answer
  7. (g) State Aristotle's dictum and its meaning.
    Read the model answer
  8. (h) Define mediate inference. Give an example.
    Read the model answer
  9. (i) Reduce directly- Darapti
    Read the model answer
  10. (j) State the types of Anumana/Nyaya logic.
    Read the model answer

Q.2 Q.2 Write short notes on (any 2 of 4) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Bob Brown's case.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Vis Major
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Prove the special rule of Fig I of categorical syllogism
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Directive and expressive use of language.
    Read the model answer

Q.3 Q.3 Solve (any 2 of 4) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Test the validity of the following categorical syllogism. Identify the figure. Give reasons.
    • (i) All philosophers are thinkers. Some students are philosophers. Therefore, some students are thinkers.
    • (ii) All healthy foods are nutritious. No candies are nutritious. Therefore, no candies are healthy foods.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Reduce Indirectly- Baroco
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Identify the following fallacy. Give reasons.
    • (i) "Your plan to reduce greenhouse gas emissions is flawed and won't work." "Why should we listen to you? Aren't you the same person who failed biology in college?"
    • (ii) During a court trial, a defense attorney says:- "My client should not be found guilty of burglary. He is the sole provider for his family, his spouse is sick, and his children depend on him. If he goes to prison, his family will suffer greatly."
    • (iii) "Reading fiction is a waste of time because it does not provide any real benefit to people."
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Identify the following fallacy if any in the following. Give reasons.
    • (i) If he goes for a movie, he misses the class. He misses the class. Therefore, he goes for a movie.
    • (ii) Either he likes sweets or junk foods. He likes sweets. Therefore, he doesn't like junk foods.
    • (iii) Not a single Indian is American. Mahesh is not an Indian. Therefore, Mahesh is not an Indian.
    Read the model answer

Q.4 Q.4 Question no 4(e) and any two from (a), (b), (c), and (d) (any 2 of 4, and 4(e)) 39 Marks

  1. (a) Explain the following- (i) Kinds of agreement and disagreement. (7) (ii) Any 3 impediments to good reasoning. 6 marks
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Explain the scientific notion of cause.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Discuss in detail verification of hypothesis.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Explain the concept of equality and justice in view of Peter Singer.
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) Construct the complex constructive dilemma, refute and rebut it. If a dam is constructed, the environment is affected, and if it is cancelled, people will face shortage of water.
    Read the model answer

Read from the scan above, so a character or two may differ. The scan is the original.

Issue

Something wrong on this page? Report it and we will check it against the scan.

Quick Help

No. The full paper opens straight away, with no login and nothing to pay.

Something wrong with this paper? Report it.

Done!
Done!