munotes®

B.A. LL.B. (Five Years) Sem 4 Logic 2 2018-19 Question Paper - Mumbai University | munotes

Logic 2 Question Paper, 2018.pdf
SEM 4 · 119 KB · 5 Aug 2026

Loading PDF...

Questions asked in this paper

  • N.B: 1. Attempt all questions. 2. Figures to the right indicate full marks.
Solved paper All 25 questions answered in full Exam-ready answers, the reasoning behind each one, and what the examiner is looking for. Open the solutions

1. Q.1 Answer in one or two sentences (all 10) 20 Marks

  1. (a) Define mediate inference, Give an example.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Give an example of ambigious minor term in categorical syllogism.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Give the symbolic expression of pure hypothetical syllogism.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Symbolise and state the Rule of Inference. If he is guilty, he will be punished. He is guilty therefore, he will be punished.
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) Symbolise and state the Rules of Replacement. 'It is false that the officer is corrupt and he has to be punished' is equivalent to 'either it is not true that the officer is corrupt and he should not be punished.
    Read the model answer
  6. (f) Give an example of Complex Destructive Dilemma.
    Read the model answer
  7. (g) Reduce directly DATISI.
    Read the model answer
  8. (h) State the difference between Modus Ponendo Tollens and Modus Tollendo Ponens.
    Read the model answer
  9. (i) What are the conditions to establish a hypothesis ?
    Read the model answer
  10. (j) Define a hypothesis.
    Read the model answer

2. Q.2 Write short notes on (any 4 of 6) 20 Marks

  1. (a) Prove the special rules of figure I of categorical syllogism.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Fallacy of petitio principii and amphiboly.
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Directive and expressive use of language.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Volunti-non-fit-injuria.
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) Any three impediments to good reasoning (Richard Feldman)
    Read the model answer
  6. (f) Emotive Words.
    Read the model answer

3. Q.3 Attempt any two questions (any 2 of 3) 12 Marks

  1. (a) Test the validity of the following categorical syllogism. Identify the figure. Give reasons.
    • (i) All rational beings are responsible for their actions. No lower animals are rational being. Therefore, No lower animals are responsible for their actions.
    • (ii) All Frenchmen are Europeans. All Germans are Europeans. Hence, all Germans are Frenchmen.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Reduce Indirectly : BAROCO
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Identify the following fallacy Give Reasons :
    • (i) The Lokpal Bill is passed by the Parliament. Mr. Tiwari is a member of the Legislative Assembly. Therefore, Mr. Tiwari must have voted in favour of it.
    • (ii) The machine is made of material substance. Therefore, Every part of machine is made of matter.
    • (iii) This strike is illegal. If the workers do not report for their duties within three days, their services will be terminated.
    Read the model answer

4. Q.4 Questions no. 4(f) and any three from Q. No. 4 (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e) (any 3 of 5, and 4(f)) 48 Marks

  1. (a) What is the dictum of Aristotle ? Show how the dictum forms the basis of all types of categorical syllogistic reasoning.
    Read the model answer
  2. (b) Explain the following : (i) Argumentum-ad-miscericordiam and Argumentum-ad-populum. (ii) Kinds of agreement and disagreement
    Read the model answer
  3. (c) Explain with examples any three kinds of Hypothesis.
    Read the model answer
  4. (d) Explain the popular notion of cause.
    Read the model answer
  5. (e) Ends justify means. Explain with reference to any two cases according to Peter Singer.
    Read the model answer
  6. (f) Construct complex constructive dilemma, rebut and refute it. If the sales tax raises prices, it benefits the producers and if it lowers the prices, it benefits the consumer.
    Read the model answer

Read from the scan above, so a character or two may differ. The scan is the original.

Issue

Something wrong on this page? Report it and we will check it against the scan.

Quick Help

No. The full paper opens straight away, with no login and nothing to pay.

Something wrong with this paper? Report it.

Done!
Done!