munotes®

LLM Foundation Course Law and Social Transformation of India 2015 Question Paper with Solutions

Mumbai University Solved Question Papers munotes.in

Law and Social Transformation of India

LLM · Foundation Course

2015 Examination

Previous Year Question Paper with Solution

munotes.in Mumbai

munotes.in

First published on munotes.in on 12 August 2026.

This edition revised 16 November 2026.

Published by munotes.in, Mumbai.

Model answers written and edited by the munotes.in editorial desk.

Passages from this volume may be quoted, in print, online or by an AI system, with credit: name munotes.in and link to this volume's page. The volume may not be reproduced as a whole. Full terms at munotes.in/content-license.

munotes.in is an independent study resource for students of the University of Mumbai. It is not affiliated with the University of Mumbai, and is not endorsed by it.

The University does not publish an official answer key for this paper. The answers in this volume are model answers, written to show how a full-mark answer is built. They are a study aid, not an authority on what an examiner marked.

The question paper reproduced here is the paper as set by the University of Mumbai at the 2015 examination.

The answers in this volume state the law as it stands today, not as it stood when the paper was set, and in this subject that reaches almost every question. The Indian Penal Code, the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Indian Evidence Act were replaced on 1 July 2024 by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, so where a question asks about a section of the old Code by number, the answer gives that section and its successor. Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure was substituted by the Mediation Act, 2023. The reservation of one third of the seats in the Lok Sabha and the State assemblies for women was notified into force on 16 April 2026 and operates after the next census and delimitation. And on 1 August 2024 seven judges held that a State may sub-classify within the Scheduled Castes.

munotes.in ii
munotes.in iii

The Paper as Set

The questions in this volume are the questions asked at the 2015 examination, reproduced as the University of Mumbai set them, in the order it set them. Nothing has been reworded, added or left out. Only the answers are ours. See the original question paper.

Duration 3 hours  ·  Total marks 100  ·  10 questions answered

How to use this volume

Solve the paper first, under exam conditions and against the clock. Then read the answers here and mark your own. Reading a solution before attempting the question feels productive and teaches very little, because recognising an answer is not the same as being able to write one.

munotes.in iv

SECTION I

Attempt any four questions, all questions carry equal marks

any four of seven · 100 Marks

munotes.in 1

1."Law is the product of tradition and culture"- Elucidate.[25]

Answer

For full marks, cover: Savigny and the historical school with the three stages; Maine's comparative account; the Indian evidence that law follows tradition, with the statutory provisions that make custom a source; the counter-evidence that law leads tradition; how the Constitution reconciles the two through a hierarchy; the practical qualification about evasion; and a conclusion that answers the quoted proposition.

1. The proposition and its author

Friedrich Carl von Savigny (1779 to 1861) was a German jurist and the founder of the historical school of jurisprudence. In 1814 he wrote Of the Vocation of Our Age for Legislation and Jurisprudence. He wrote it against Thibaut, who wanted German law codified on the French model.

Savigny's thesis is that law is not made but found. It grows with a people, as its language does. It expresses the Volksgeist, which means the common consciousness or spirit of a people. So law cannot be transplanted from one society to another.

He described three stages.

munotes.in 2
  1. In the customary stage, law lives in the popular consciousness. People practise it without writing it down.
  2. In the juristic stage, lawyers become its technical custodians, and the law takes a scientific form. Savigny saw this stage as necessary but risky.
  3. In the legislative stage, law is made by a legislature, and its link with the people is lost. Savigny treated this stage as decay.

Georg Friedrich Puchta took the thesis to its extreme. He treated the Volksgeist as the only source of law.

2. Maine's comparative version

Sir Henry Maine wrote Ancient Law in 1861. He traced a progression in three steps:

  1. themistes, which were isolated judgments that people believed the gods had inspired;
  2. custom, kept by a privileged order such as priests;
  3. codes, once writing made it possible to publish the law.
munotes.in 3

He then separated static societies from progressive societies. Static societies stop at the code. Progressive societies develop their law further by legal fiction, equity and legislation. A legal fiction is something the law assumes to be true, though it is not, in order to reach a fair result. Equity is a body of rules based on fairness that corrects the strict law.

His most quoted proposition is about progressive societies. Their movement has so far been a movement from status to contract. Status means duties fixed by the group into which a person is born. Contract means duties that a person creates by agreement.

Maine compared Roman, Hindu and Irish law. That method makes him more useful for India than Savigny, whose theory assumed a single organic people.

3. The Indian evidence for the proposition

Custom is a formal source of Indian law. A formal source is one from which a rule gets its binding force. Article 13(3)(a) of the Constitution includes custom and usage having the force of law within the definition of "law". This recognises the proposition. As will appear, it also sets its limit.

munotes.in 4

Section 3(a) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 defines custom and usage. They mean any rule which, "having been continuously and uniformly observed for a long time, has obtained the force of law" among Hindus in a local area, tribe, community, group or family. The rule must also be certain, and not unreasonable or opposed to public policy. A rule that applies only to a family must not have been discontinued by that family.

Section 29(2) of the same Act expressly saves a right, recognised by custom, to obtain the dissolution of a Hindu marriage. Dissolution means ending a marriage by divorce.

Among Muslims, the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937 makes Muslim personal law the rule of decision in the matters it lists. These include marriage, divorce, maintenance and succession. It applies "notwithstanding any custom or usage to the contrary". So custom still governs Muslims only outside those matters, for example in agricultural land, which the Act leaves out.

Tribal custom governs succession among the Scheduled Tribes. Section 2(2) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 keeps members of the Scheduled Tribes outside that Act, unless the Central Government directs otherwise. So their own customs decide who inherits.

munotes.in 5

The essentials of a valid custom are themselves an admission that tradition is a source. A valid custom must be:

  1. ancient or immemorial, that is, very old;
  2. continuous;
  3. peaceable, that is, followed without dispute;
  4. certain;
  5. reasonable;
  6. obligatory rather than optional, that is, followed because people feel bound by it;
  7. consistent with statute and public policy.

Codified statutes carry tradition inside them. The Hindu Marriage Act kept the customary ceremonies as the test of a valid marriage. Under Section 7, a Hindu marriage may be solemnized according to the customary rites and ceremonies of either party.

munotes.in 6

Bhaurao Shankar Lokhande v. State of Maharashtra AIR 1965 SC 1564. The accused was prosecuted for bigamy, which means marrying again while the first spouse is alive. His second marriage had been performed without the two essential ceremonies of a Hindu marriage. These are the invocation before the sacred fire and the saptapadi, the seven steps the couple take before that fire. No custom was proved that allowed those ceremonies to be left out. So the Court held that the second marriage had not been "solemnized" in law, and the prosecution for bigamy failed. Tradition decided the result inside a codified statute.

The Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 kept an old rule of Hindu law. Under Section 11(i), a person who already has a living Hindu son, son's son or son's son's son cannot adopt a son. It also added new rules, such as an age gap of at least twenty-one years where the child is of the opposite sex.

The Indian Contract Act, 1872 recognises usage of trade. Its Section 1 saves any usage or custom of trade that is not inconsistent with the Act.

munotes.in 7

Personal law is tradition given legal effect. It survives in a modern constitutional State. Different communities still have different rules of marriage, divorce, guardianship and succession. This is the strongest single illustration of the proposition.

4. The evidence against the proposition

Transplants took root. The Indian Penal Code, 1860, the Indian Contract Act, 1872 and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 were drafted on English models. They were made for a society whose Volksgeist had nothing to do with them. Yet they governed for more than a century and a half.

The Penal Code was replaced only by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, with effect from 1 July 2024. The Evidence Act gave way to the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 on the same day. The Contract Act is still in force. Savigny's strong claim was that imported law stays lifeless. The most important body of law India had disproves it.

The Constitution did the opposite of recording tradition. Article 17 abolished untouchability, against the practice of centuries. Untouchability is the practice of treating some castes as impure and keeping them apart. Article 17 made the enforcement of any disability arising out of it an offence. This rule binds private persons too, not only the State.

munotes.in 8

The Hindu Code Bills were passed against strong orthodox opposition. They abolished polygamy for Hindus, that is, having more than one wife at a time. They permitted divorce. They gave the widow and the daughter rights of inheritance.

Article 13(1) makes pre-Constitution law void to the extent that it is inconsistent with the fundamental rights. Clause (3)(a) puts custom inside that discipline, because it counts custom as "law".

And the courts have struck down tradition, or held it back.

Shayara Bano v. Union of India (2017) 9 SCC 1. Shayara Bano's husband divorced her by instantaneous triple talaq, that is, by pronouncing "talaq" three times at once. By a majority of three to two, the Supreme Court set the practice aside, although it was a practice of long usage.

munotes.in 9

Madhu Kishwar v. State of Bihar (1996) 5 SCC 125. Tribal women challenged the custom, recognised in the Chotanagpur Tenancy Act, 1908, that only male heirs inherit tribal land. The Court tested this custom on succession against Articles 14 and 15. The majority did not strike the custom down. But it held that the male heirs' right to take the land stays suspended. It stays suspended as long as the widow or daughter depends on the land for her livelihood. K. Ramaswamy J, in a separate opinion, would have given tribal women equal rights of succession.

Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala (2019) 11 SCC 1, decided on 28 September 2018. The Sabarimala temple kept out women aged ten to fifty. The legal basis was Rule 3(b) of the Kerala Hindu Places of Public Worship (Authorisation of Entry) Rules, 1965. The exclusion was defended as an ancient tradition. By four to one, the Court opened the temple to them. The majority held that the exclusion violated the women's freedom of religion under Article 25(1). Chandrachud J went further. He held that exclusion founded on notions of impurity offends Articles 15 and 17.

munotes.in 10

5. How Indian law reconciles the two: a hierarchy, not a compromise

Tradition supplies the material. Custom and personal law remain sources of law. A court will apply a custom that satisfies the tests above.

The Constitution then decides which parts of that material may survive. It does this through Article 13, Article 15, Article 17 and, most explicitly, Article 25(2)(b). Article 25(2)(b) permits laws for social welfare and reform. It also permits laws throwing open Hindu religious institutions of a public character to all classes and sections of Hindus. Both powers sit inside the guarantee of religious freedom itself.

One complication in the law must be stated.

State of Bombay v. Narasu Appa Mali AIR 1952 Bom 84. The Bombay Prevention of Hindu Bigamous Marriages Act, 1946 was challenged because it barred bigamy only for Hindus. The Bombay High Court upheld the Act. It also held that uncodified personal law is not "law in force" under Article 13. Uncodified means not written down in a statute. So such personal law cannot be tested against the fundamental rights.

munotes.in 11

That decision is the reason unequal personal law has survived more than seventy years of Part III. Nariman J in Shayara Bano and Chandrachud J in Sabarimala both cast doubt on it. It has not been overruled.

6. The practical qualification, which is Savigny's real insight

A law with no support in the culture is evaded rather than obeyed. To evade a law is to get around it without openly breaking it. The Indian record shows this again and again.

  1. Dowry has spread since it was prohibited in 1961.
  2. Child marriage persists despite the Act of 2006.
  3. Land ceiling laws were defeated by benami transfers. A benami transfer is one made in another person's name, to hide the real owner.
  4. Manual scavenging is prohibited, and it continues.

Vilhelm Aubert, a Norwegian sociologist of law, studied how legislation changes behaviour. His studies and the Indian record agree on four conditions of success:

  1. the rule must be precise;
  2. the beneficiary must be able to enforce it herself;
munotes.in 12
  1. a funded institution must deliver it;
  2. no strong contrary norm inside the group must protect the prohibited conduct.

Conclusion. The proposition is true of the origins of law and false of its authority. Indian law is the product of tradition and culture in one sense. Custom and personal law are formal sources, and codified statutes carry inherited content. But it is not a product of tradition in the sense Savigny meant. Since 1950, the constitutional order has claimed the right to decide which traditions the law will support. The accurate formulation, and the one to end on, is this. Tradition supplies the material on which the legal order works, and the Constitution supplies the standard by which that material is kept or discarded. That standard is what Pound would call the jural postulates of the society India has chosen to become. Jural postulates are the basic ideas of justice that a society takes for granted.

munotes.in 13

The rest of the answers

The first answer is free. The rest come with the solved papers for your group.

You have read the question paper and its first answer in full. Buy the solved papers once and you can read every answer of every solved paper in this semester. Choose your group on the next page.

Notes + Solved papers: ₹798 Already bought it? Sign in

Or solved papers only: ₹499
Or notes only: ₹499

The question paper itself stays free, and so does the syllabus.

Issue

Found an error in this volume? Report it and we will check it against the paper.

Done!