munotes®

LLM Foundation Course Indian Constitutional Law New Challenges 2023 Question Paper with Solutions

Mumbai University Solved Question Papers munotes.in

Indian Constitutional Law New Challenges

LLM · Foundation Course

2023 Examination

Previous Year Question Paper with Solution

munotes.in Mumbai

munotes.in

First published on munotes.in on 12 August 2026.

This edition revised 15 November 2026.

Published by munotes.in, Mumbai.

Model answers written and edited by the munotes.in editorial desk.

Passages from this volume may be quoted, in print, online or by an AI system, with credit: name munotes.in and link to this volume's page. The volume may not be reproduced as a whole. Full terms at munotes.in/content-license.

munotes.in is an independent study resource for students of the University of Mumbai. It is not affiliated with the University of Mumbai, and is not endorsed by it.

The University does not publish an official answer key for this paper. The answers in this volume are model answers, written to show how a full-mark answer is built. They are a study aid, not an authority on what an examiner marked.

The question paper reproduced here is the paper as set by the University of Mumbai at the 2023 examination.

The answers in this volume state the law as it stands today, not as it stood when the paper was set, and in this subject the difference is large. Five changes alter answers here. Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal, 8 November 2024, overruled Azeez Basha on the minority status of an institution incorporated by statute. State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh, 1 August 2024, permitted sub-classification within the Scheduled Castes. The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023 replaced the appointment committee directed in Anoop Baranwal. The Constitution (One Hundred and Sixth Amendment) Act, 2023 came into force on 16 April 2026 and is not yet operative. And the advisory opinion of 20 November 2025 held that no timeline may be set for assent to a Bill. Where a provision has since been replaced, the answer gives the position then and now, and says which is which.

munotes.in ii
munotes.in iii

The Paper as Set

The questions in this volume are the questions asked at the 2023 examination, reproduced as the University of Mumbai set them, in the order it set them. Nothing has been reworded, added or left out. Only the answers are ours. See the original question paper.

Duration 3 hours  ·  Total marks 100  ·  7 questions answered

How to use this volume

Solve the paper first, under exam conditions and against the clock. Then read the answers here and mark your own. Reading a solution before attempting the question feels productive and teaches very little, because recognising an answer is not the same as being able to write one.

munotes.in iv

SECTION I

Answer any four questions, all questions carry equal marks

any four of seven · 100 Marks

munotes.in 1

1.Explain the need for redefining the "State" in view of the policy of economic Liberalization.[25]

Answer

For full marks, cover: what the 1991 policy actually changed; why Article 12 was drafted for a different economy; the mechanism by which liberalisation narrows Part III, with BALCO as the proof; the three doctrinal routes available for redefining State, and which of them the courts have in fact taken; and a conclusion that answers whether redefinition is needed or whether the answer lies elsewhere.

1. What liberalisation changed

What liberalisation changed. India changed its economic policy in 1991. Liberalisation means reducing government control over the economy and opening it to private business. The New Industrial Policy of 24 July 1991 made four big changes.

  1. It abolished industrial licensing for most industries. Before this, a licence from the government was needed to set up or expand a factory.
  2. It cut the number of industries reserved for the public sector from seventeen to eight. Later the list fell to three. Today only two remain reserved: atomic energy and railway operations.
munotes.in 2
  1. It opened most sectors to foreign direct investment, that is, investment by foreign companies in Indian businesses.
  2. It began disinvestment in public sector undertakings. Disinvestment means the government selling its shares in the companies it owns.

Since then, the State has withdrawn from many fields. They include telecommunications, aviation, airports, ports and power distribution. It has partly withdrawn from banking. It is withdrawing more and more from health and education. In many of these fields it has come back in a new role. It now acts as a regulator, which makes and enforces the rules of a field. Or it acts as a contracting party, which buys services under a contract. It no longer acts as the owner.

2. Why this matters for Part III

Why that matters for Part III, in one step. Part III of the Constitution holds the fundamental rights, and most of them bind only "the State". Article 12 defines "the State" for Part III. It includes four kinds of body.

  1. The Government and Parliament of India.
  2. The Governments and Legislatures of the States.
munotes.in 3
  1. All local authorities.
  2. Other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.

Everything turns on the words "other authorities". The test for them comes from Pradeep Kumar Biswas v. Indian Institute of Chemical Biology (2002) 5 SCC 111. A body is State if it is under the financial, functional and administrative domination or control by the Government. That control must be particular to the body. It must also be pervasive, which means it runs through the body's whole working. Merely regulatory control will not do. Regulatory control means general rules that apply to every body in a field.

Every one of those criteria is a criterion of ownership and control. So as the State stops owning bodies, fewer bodies pass the test. The reach of Articles 14, 15, 16, 19 and 21 falls with it. This happens without a single word of the Constitution being amended.

3. The proof: BALCO

The proof is BALCO. The case is BALCO Employees' Union v. Union of India (2002) 2 SCC 333. The Union sold its fifty-one per cent holding in Bharat Aluminium Company to a private buyer. The employees challenged the sale. The Court upheld it, and gave three reasons.

munotes.in 4
  1. Disinvestment is a matter of economic policy.
  2. The Court has no expertise to sit in judgment over such a policy.
  3. The employees had no right to be heard. A change of ownership affected no right of theirs.

The constitutional result is stark, and the Court did not deny it. On the day before the sale, an employee could move the High Court under Article 226 for a breach of Article 14 or Article 16. On the day after the sale, the employee could not. The employer had ceased to be State.

4. The same problem in three other forms

The same problem in three other forms. The State does not need to sell a company for Part III to shrink.

  1. Public private partnership. An airport, a highway or a hospital may be run under a concession. A concession is a long-term grant that lets a private company run a public facility. The company performs a public function with State assets, but it is privately owned. No test of pervasive control will catch it.
munotes.in 5
  1. Outsourcing. A government department may contract out a service to a private firm. The firm's employees are then outside Article 16. The users of the service are outside Article 14 as against that firm.
  2. The regulated private monopoly. A private distribution licensee may be the only supplier of electricity in a city. Yet on Federal Bank Ltd. v. Sagar Thomas (2003) 10 SCC 733, extensive regulation is not control. So the licensee is not State.

5. Three routes to redefinition

So is redefinition needed, and if so how? Three routes are available, and they should be assessed.

Route one, widen "other authorities" further. The courts have refused to take this route. In Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India (2005) 4 SCC 649, the Board of Control for Cricket in India was held not to be State. The Board has a monopoly in fact. It selects the national team. It enjoys official recognition. Even so, it failed every one of the Pradeep Kumar Biswas criteria. To catch a truly private operator, the test would have to be abandoned, not widened. And a definition that catches every powerful private body is no definition at all.

munotes.in 6

The argument against this route is not technical but structural. Part III was drafted to bind the State because the State has coercive power, the power to force people by law. Stretching Part III to bind everyone would turn every private dispute into a constitutional one.

Route two, shift the question from what the body is to what it does. This is the route the courts have actually taken. It runs through Article 226, not Article 32.

  1. Andi Mukta Sadguru Shree Muktajee Vandas Swami Suvarna Jayanti Mahotsav Smarak Trust v. V.R. Rudani (1989) 2 SCC 691 held that a writ of mandamus lies against any person or body performing a public duty. Mandamus is a court order that directs a person or body to perform a public duty. The body's constitutional status does not matter, because Article 226 extends to "any other purpose".
  2. Zee Telefilms itself kept this remedy open against the Board.
  3. K.K. Saksena v. International Commission on Irrigation and Drainage (2015) 4 SCC 670 sets the limit. The duty must be a public duty, imposed by statute or by the nature of the function. A duty owed to members of the public only under a contract is not enough.
munotes.in 7

This route has two weaknesses. First, it is available only in the High Courts, not under Article 32. Second, it enforces public duties, not fundamental rights as such.

Route three, horizontality. Horizontality means that a fundamental right can be enforced against a private person, not only against the State. Kaushal Kishor v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2023) 4 SCC 1 was decided on 3 January 2023, five months before this paper was set. A bench of five decided it by 4:1, and it held two things.

  1. The rights under Articles 19 and 21 may be enforced against persons other than the State and its instrumentalities. An instrumentality is a body through which the State acts.
  2. The State has a positive duty to protect a person's Article 21 rights, even against a threat from a private person.

So Articles 19 and 21 join Articles 15(2), 17, 23, 24 and 29(2), which are horizontal on their own terms. If this holding is worked out, the need to redefine "State" largely disappears for the two most important rights in Part III. The right will run directly against the private actor. Two things call for caution. Nagarathna J. partly dissented. And there is not yet a developed set of remedies for enforcing these rights against private persons.

munotes.in 8

6. Two answers outside the Constitution

Two further answers that are not constitutional at all, and a complete answer notes them.

  1. Statute. The Right to Information Act, 2005 reaches private bodies that are "substantially financed" by the government, through section 2(h). Other laws and regulators do the work that Part III cannot do. Examples are the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 and the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. The regulators of particular sectors, such as electricity and telecommunications, do the same.
  2. Conditions in the transfer itself. A disinvestment or concession agreement can carry obligations. They may cover employment, tariffs (the prices charged to users) and non-discrimination. This protection is contractual, not constitutional. But it is enforceable and specific.
munotes.in 9

Conclusion. The need to redefine "State" arises because Article 12 measures a body by how far the Government owns and controls it. Liberalisation has reduced Government ownership. It has not reduced the public importance of what these bodies do. BALCO shows the consequence. Part III retreats every time a public enterprise is sold, though nobody voted to reduce fundamental rights. But stretching "other authorities" is not the right answer, and the Supreme Court has refused it. Control is the only principled test available, and Zee Telefilms shows what happens when control is absent. The workable answers are the two the courts have actually developed. The first is the public function jurisdiction under Article 226, which asks what the body does, not what it is. The second is the horizontal enforcement of Articles 19 and 21 recognised in Kaushal Kishor. Redefinition is therefore needed, but of the reach of the rights, not of the definition of the State.

munotes.in 10

The rest of the answers

The first answer is free. The rest come with the solved papers for your group.

You have read the question paper and its first answer in full. Buy the solved papers once and you can read every answer of every solved paper in this semester. Choose your group on the next page.

Notes + Solved papers: ₹798 Already bought it? Sign in

Or solved papers only: ₹499
Or notes only: ₹499

The question paper itself stays free, and so does the syllabus.

Issue

Found an error in this volume? Report it and we will check it against the paper.

Done!