Allowances for Stamps
Chapter Sixty-Nine
Syllabus topic 4.2, "Allowances for Stamps [Sections 47 - 52B]"
Pages 363 to 368 of 378
In one line
Where a stamp has been spoilt, used for a document that never took effect, or simply not needed, the Collector may allow its value back, and above a threshold the decision is taken higher up.
In exam wording: section 47 provides that, subject to rules as to evidence and enquiry, the Collector may, on application made within the period prescribed by section 48, and if satisfied as to the facts, make allowance for impressed stamps spoiled in the cases the section sets out.
Why the Act allows anything back
Stamp duty is a tax on an instrument. Where the instrument never came into effective existence, or where the stamp was spoilt before it could be used, no taxable event has really occurred, and to keep the money would be to tax nothing.
The Act is nevertheless careful. Allowances are a route by which the revenue can be drained, so every head is defined, there are short time limits under section 48, and above a threshold the decision is taken away from the Collector under section 52A.
Section 47: the heads of allowance
The Collector may make allowance for impressed stamps spoiled in these cases:
(a) the stamp on paper inadvertently and undesignedly spoiled, obliterated, or by error in writing or otherwise rendered unfit for the purpose intended, before any instrument written on it is executed by any person;
(b) the stamp on a document written out wholly or in part but not signed or executed by any party;
(c) the stamp used for an instrument executed by a party which:
- has afterwards been found by the party to be absolutely void in law from the beginning;
- is found unfit, by reason of an error or mistake in it, for the purpose originally intended;
- by reason of the death of a person by whom it must be executed, or the refusal of any person to act under it, or the refusal of any person to advance money intended to be secured by it, or the refusal or failure of any person to perform some act intended to be performed by it, cannot be completed;
- for want of the execution of some material part by a person whose execution was necessary, is inoperative;
- is wholly useless because the purpose intended cannot be carried out;
- becomes useless in consequence of the transaction being effected by some other instrument between the same parties and bearing the proper duty.
The proviso to that last group requires, in the case of an executed instrument, that no legal proceeding has been commenced in which the instrument could or would have been given in evidence, and that the instrument is given up to be cancelled, or has already been given up to the Court to be cancelled.
Allowances for Stamps
The Explanation provides that the Collector's certificate under section 32 that the full duty has been paid is an impressed stamp within the meaning of this section, which is what lets an adjudicated instrument be brought within the allowance provisions.
Section 48: the time limits
Applications for relief under section 47 must be made:
(1) in the cases in clause (c)(5), within one year of the date of the instrument;
The proviso, a modern and practically important addition: where an agreement to sell immovable property on which duty was paid under Article 25 of Schedule I has been registered, and is afterwards cancelled by a registered cancellation deed for whatever reason, before possession of the property is taken, within five years of the execution of the agreement, the application for relief may be made within one year of the date of registration of the cancellation deed.
That proviso matters to any student who will practise conveyancing in Maharashtra: it is the route by which duty on a cancelled flat booking can be recovered.
(2) where, for unavoidable circumstances, an instrument for which another has been substituted cannot be given up to be cancelled, within one year after the date of execution of the substituted instrument;
(3) in any other case, within one year from the date of purchase of the stamps.
The period is one year throughout, having been shortened from the longer periods in the original Act.
Sections 49 to 52: the other allowances
Section 49: printed forms no longer required by corporations. The Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, or the Collector if so empowered, may without limit of time make allowance for stamped papers used for printed forms of instruments by a banker, incorporated company or body corporate, where the forms have ceased to be required, provided the authority is satisfied that the duty was duly paid. Note the absence of a time limit, which is the exception to section 48.
Section 50: misused stamps. Where a stamp has been used for an instrument for which it was not intended, or of greater value than was necessary, allowance may be made in the circumstances the section provides.
Section 51: allowance for spoiled or misused stamps how to be made. The allowance may be made by giving other stamps of the same or another description of the same value, or, at the Collector's discretion, by repayment in money, deducting the prescribed amount.
Section 52: allowance for stamps not required for use. Where a person is possessed of a stamp which has not been spoiled or rendered unfit or useless for its intended purpose, but for which he has no immediate use, the Collector shall repay the value in money, deducting the prescribed amount, on the person delivering up the stamp and proving to the Collector's satisfaction that it was purchased by him with a bona fide intention to use it, that he paid the full price, and that it was purchased within the period prescribed.
Allowances for Stamps
Section 52A: where the amount is large
As the consolidated text of 8 April 2025 stands, section 52A(1) provides that notwithstanding sections 47, 50, 51 and 52, where payment of duty was made by stamps or in cash under section 10(3), 10A or 10B, and the amount of duty paid exceeds five lakh rupees, the Collector shall not himself make the allowance, but shall, after making necessary enquiries, forward the application with his remarks to the authority the section names.
The Maharashtra Stamp (Amendment) Act 2026, in force 7 April 2026, changed this in two ways.
First, in sub-section (1) the words "five lakhs" were replaced by "twenty lakhs". So the Collector now retains the power to allow up to twenty lakh rupees, and only above that must he refer.
Second, sub-section (2) was substituted with a new tiered structure. On receiving such an application:
- the Additional Controller of Stamps, where the allowance is above twenty lakh and up to one crore rupees;
- the Joint Inspector General of Registration and Superintendent of Stamps, where it is above fifty lakh and up to one crore rupees;
- the concerned Deputy Inspector General of Registration and Deputy Controller of Stamps of the Division, where it is above twenty lakh and up to fifty lakh rupees,
shall consider the application and decide whether the allowance shall be given, and grant it accordingly. And where the amount exceeds one crore rupees, those authorities must submit the application with their remarks to the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority for decision.
The amendment also inserted, in sub-section (1)(b), a reference to the Joint Inspector General of Registration and Superintendent of Stamps alongside the concerned officer.
A caution about the commentary. A widely syndicated note on this amendment states that the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority takes cases "exceeding Rs. 2 crores". The enacted text says one crore. The figures above are taken from the legislature's own print.
Section 52B provides that certain stamps are not valid after the period it prescribes, and that stamps purchased but not used within that period may be dealt with as it provides, which is the companion to the allowance scheme.
Allowances for Stamps
A worked example
Manjiri buys stamp paper worth Rs. 3 lakh for a conveyance at Kolhapur.
She spoils it in writing before anyone signs. Section 47(a): allowance may be made for a stamp inadvertently and undesignedly spoiled before any instrument written on it is executed. She applies within one year of purchase under section 48(3).
She had signed, and the deed turns out to be void from the beginning. Section 47(c)(1). But the proviso requires that no legal proceeding has been commenced in which the instrument could have been given in evidence, and that the instrument is given up to be cancelled.
She books a flat by a registered agreement to sell on which duty is paid under Article 25, and cancels it by a registered cancellation deed three years later, before taking possession. The proviso to section 48(1) applies: she may apply for relief within one year of the registration of the cancellation deed.
She has stamp paper she simply no longer needs. Section 52: the Collector shall repay the value in money, less the prescribed deduction, on her delivering it up and proving a bona fide intention to use it, payment of the full price, and purchase within the prescribed period.
Now change the amount. Suppose the duty paid was Rs. 60 lakh.
Before 7 April 2026, section 52A required the Collector to refer any allowance where the duty exceeded five lakh.
After 7 April 2026, the threshold is twenty lakh, so the Collector must still refer. The amount being above fifty lakh and up to one crore, the application goes to the Joint Inspector General of Registration and Superintendent of Stamps, who decides.
Suppose it were Rs. 30 lakh. Above twenty lakh and up to fifty lakh, so the Deputy Inspector General of Registration and Deputy Controller of Stamps of the Division decides.
Suppose it were Rs. 1.5 crore. Exceeding one crore, so the application is submitted with remarks to the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority for decision.
Suppose it were Rs. 15 lakh. Under the amended section the Collector himself may make the allowance, which he could not have done before the amendment.
What it does NOT mean
Allowance is not automatic. The Collector must be satisfied as to the facts, and rules govern the evidence and enquiry.
It is not available at any time. Section 48 imposes a one-year limit in each case, save for section 49, which has none.
An executed instrument is not always allowable. The proviso requires that no legal proceeding has begun and that the instrument is given up to be cancelled.
Section 52A does not refuse the allowance. It moves the decision to a higher authority above the threshold.
Allowances for Stamps
The threshold is no longer five lakh. Since 7 April 2026 it is twenty lakh.
The Chief Controlling Revenue Authority's floor is one crore, not two.
Distinctions
| Amount of allowance | Who decides, from 7 April 2026 |
|---|---|
| Up to Rs. 20 lakh | The Collector himself |
| Above Rs. 20 lakh and up to Rs. 50 lakh | The Deputy Inspector General of Registration and Deputy Controller of Stamps of the Division |
| Above Rs. 20 lakh and up to Rs. 1 crore | The Additional Controller of Stamps |
| Above Rs. 50 lakh and up to Rs. 1 crore | The Joint Inspector General of Registration and Superintendent of Stamps |
| Exceeding Rs. 1 crore | The Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, on a reference with remarks |
| Application under | Time limit, s.48 |
|---|---|
| s.47(c)(5) | One year of the date of the instrument |
| A registered agreement to sell cancelled by registered deed before possession, within five years | One year from registration of the cancellation deed |
| A substituted instrument that cannot be given up | One year after execution of the substituted instrument |
| Any other case | One year from the date of purchase of the stamps |
| s.49, corporate printed forms | No limit of time |
Quick revision
- s.47: allowance for impressed stamps spoiled, in the listed cases, on application within the s.48 period and if the Collector is satisfied. The s.32 certificate counts as an impressed stamp.
- For an executed instrument: no proceeding begun, and the instrument given up to be cancelled.
- s.48: one year throughout; and a registered agreement to sell cancelled by a registered deed before possession, within five years, gives one year from the cancellation deed's registration.
- s.49: corporate printed forms, allowance without limit of time. s.50 misused stamps. s.51 allowance by other stamps or by repayment in money less the deduction. s.52 stamps not required for use, repaid on proof of bona fide purchase at full price within the prescribed period.
- s.52A, as amended 7 April 2026: the Collector may allow up to twenty lakh (formerly five lakh); above that the tiered authorities decide; above one crore it goes to the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority.
- s.52B: stamps not valid after the prescribed period.
Test yourself
1. Name four cases in which allowance may be made for a spoiled stamp. A stamp inadvertently and undesignedly spoiled before execution; a stamp on a document written out but not signed or executed; a stamp on an executed instrument found by the party to be absolutely void from the beginning; and a stamp on an instrument that cannot be completed by reason of a death, a refusal to act, a refusal to advance money, or a failure to perform an intended act.
Allowances for Stamps
2. What conditions attach to an allowance for an executed instrument? That no legal proceeding has been commenced in which the instrument could or would have been given or offered in evidence, and that the instrument is given up to be cancelled or has already been given up to the Court to be cancelled.
3. What is the general time limit under section 48, and which provision has none? One year, computed as the section directs in each case. Section 49, allowance for corporate printed forms no longer required, may be made without limit of time.
4. A registered agreement to sell is cancelled by a registered cancellation deed before possession. When must the application be made? Within one year from the date of registration of the cancellation deed, provided the cancellation occurred within five years of the execution of the agreement and before possession was taken.
5. Up to what amount may the Collector himself make an allowance? Twenty lakh rupees, since the amendment in force on 7 April 2026. Before that the figure was five lakh.
6. Who decides where the allowance exceeds one crore rupees? The Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, the other authorities submitting the application with their remarks for decision.
7. In what forms may an allowance be given? By other stamps of the same or another description of the same value, or, at the Collector's discretion, by repayment in money, deducting the prescribed amount.
The rest of this subject
These notes are cut from the University's printed syllabus. Open the syllabus itself, or the past papers, for the same subject.